How to migrate an email list from one email service provider to another
Migrating your email list from one email provider to another can be a daunting task.
I have personally migrated from AWeber to GetResponse.
From GetResponse to Flodesk.
And have helped others migrate away from their email service provider to another.
The software tools I’ve done this with are MailChimp, MailerLite, MooSend, Kajabi, Kartra, Podia, Klaviyo, ConvertKit, systeme.io, Zenler, and more.
No matter what software you are using, here are the basic steps:
(1) Export subscriber CSV:
Export your email list as a CSV from your current email service provider.
(2) New software free trial:
Sign up for a free trial with your new email service provider (they all offer a free trial). Do not pay yet.
(3) Upload subscriber list to new software:
Upload the CSV to the new service provider. They all have a support document that shows step by step how to do it as they WANT to make it easy to move away from other competitors. Find that tutorial for the particular email service provider and follow it.
(4) Confirm CSV upload is complete:
Once uploaded, wait for the confirmation email that the list was uploaded. As needed email support to check that it was all done correctly. Compare how many got uploaded versus how many names are on the CSV. Chances are it is a lower number. Not much you can do about that. It happens.
(5) Send an email to your list from the new provider:
Send an email from the new email service provider, broadcast email. And make sure you tell people to REPLY to your email to let you know they received it. And save your email address as a contact.
(6) Evaluate deliverability:
Have a look at the deliverability statistics at the new email provider. If you are getting responses from people, if there are opens and clicks, it means your email is not going to spam. If you know people on your list personally, reach out to them on FB or Instagram to also check if they received it.
(7) Improve deliverability:
One of the most common problems people complain about with migrating from one email software to another is this:
“my emails are going to spam.”
They blame the email software, where usually, the problem is their emails.
Here is a support document from Google on things you need to do to avoid having your emails being filtered to spam (a lot of your subscribers are Gmail users).
Find out from your new email provider the support document showing how to “verify your domain”. These are simple steps to verify your domain is authenticated which will greatly increase your deliverability. Anyone that has ever complained to me about “my email is going to spam”, gets asked by me, “did you verify your domain?”
100% of the time, they have no idea what I’m talking about.
Now you do.
So ask your new provider for the instructions on how to do it and follow it.
Here are examples for email domain verification for various software tools:
If you need additional help with your particular domain or email provider, that is exactly what my tech support membership is there for.
To help you with questions like this, for some may take hours or even days to find the answer – whereas my paid members can email my helpdesk and get the answer they are looking for under 24 hours.
PRO TIP: Always be subscribed to your own list using a fake email address.
Eran Bucai
Pro tip: Always be subscribed to your own list using a fake email address.
I always recommend my clients to have a learning email address where they can subscribe to people’s lists purely to learn about other people’s marketing and get inspiration, e.g. learning.yourname@gmail.com
If you need help choosing the best email marketing software, or get help with the above process, reach out to me by filling out this form.
I have recorded a training video in my paid tech support membership about how to choose the best software for your business, email marketing, and otherwise.
Eran Bucai